Save
These Cookie Monster cookies are bursting with color and flavor making them the ultimate party treat for kids and grown ups alike. Each oversized cookie has a gooey center thanks to a surprise Oreo hidden inside and every bite is absolutely loaded with chocolate chips and crunchy cookie bits. If you are looking to make an unforgettable batch of cookies this is the recipe that will win over every sweet tooth in the room.
The first time I made these my nieces actually squealed when they saw the blue dough and now they beg to help add the Oreos and chocolate chips each time we bake together.
Ingredients
- Unsalted butter: softened adds richness and helps the cookies stay soft look for a pale yellow color for best flavor
- Granulated sugar: creates crisp edges use fresh sugar to ensure smooth creaming
- Light brown sugar: adds depth and chewiness choose one that is moist when squeezed
- Egg: at room temperature binds the dough and creates tenderness use the freshest eggs you can find
- Vanilla extract: adds warmth and sweetness pure extract really shines here
- Blue gel food coloring: gives the bright blue Cookie Monster color use gel for the most vibrant shade
- All purpose flour: forms the cookies’ structure look for unbleached for a richer flavor
- Salt: balances the sweetness a pinch is all you need
- Baking powder: gives height and softness ensure it is not expired
- Baking soda: helps cookies spread just enough double check it is fresh
- Dark chocolate chips: melt into ribbons of chocolate pick high cocoa content for rich flavor
- White chocolate chips: add pops of creamy sweetness try to get ones with real cocoa butter
- Crushed mini cookies: bring crunch and fun bits throughout sprinkle with your favorites
- Chopped Oreos: add extra cookies and cream pockets classic flavor works best
- Whole Oreos: for stuffing each cookie gets its own surprise go with original
Instructions
- Mix the Butter and Sugars:
- In a large bowl thoroughly beat softened butter with both sugars for two full minutes until the mixture is creamy pale and fluffy. This step creates a light base and helps the cookies bake up nice and thick.
- Add Wet Ingredients and Color:
- Drop in the egg vanilla extract and a generous squeeze of blue gel food coloring. Mix until completely smooth and even, making sure the blue is fully incorporated so you get that signature Cookie Monster hue.
- Fold in Dry Ingredients:
- Sift flour salt baking powder and baking soda right into the bowl. Gently fold the dry mix into the wet batter with a spatula. Stir just until combined so the dough stays tender.
- Mix in Goodies:
- Add both types of chocolate chips crushed mini cookies and chopped Oreos. Fold everything together so every scoop contains a bit of each treat.
- Chill the Dough:
- Cover the bowl with plastic wrap and chill in the fridge for at least thirty minutes. This firms up the dough and allows the flavors to meld making for thicker cookies.
- Shape and Fill:
- Scoop out portions of dough slightly bigger than a golf ball. Flatten each piece gently in your hand, place a whole Oreo cookie in the center, then carefully wrap the blue dough all around the Oreo and seal tight.
- Final Chill:
- Arrange cookies on a lined baking tray and chill again for thirty more minutes in the fridge or fifteen in the freezer. This keeps cookies from spreading too much when they bake.
- Bake to Perfection:
- Bake at one hundred eighty degrees Celsius or three hundred fifty degrees Fahrenheit for about twelve to fifteen minutes. The edges should be turning golden but the dough in the center should stay soft and puffy.
- Cool and Enjoy:
- Allow cookies to cool on the tray a few minutes to set the shape. Transfer to a wire rack to finish cooling and enjoy those gooey middles.
Crushed mini cookies are definitely my sneaky favorite the little pockets of crunch make each day old cookie just as good as the first. Last time, my nephew announced mid bite that this was the happiest cookie he ever ate.
Storage Tips
Store your Cookie Monster cookies in an airtight container at room temperature for up to seven days. For longer storage pop them in the freezer in a zip top bag and thaw or microwave when ready. I find the centers stay soft even after freezing.
Ingredient Substitutions
If you are out of baking soda you can use an extra quarter teaspoon of baking powder. Any dairy free butter sticks can be swapped for regular to make these cookies lactose free. For mix ins mini chocolate chip cookies or even animal crackers work great if you do not have Oreos.
Serving Suggestions
Pile these cookies onto a birthday party tray with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. Crumble half a cookie over a milkshake for an over the top dessert. Or simply share one fresh from the oven with a tall glass of milk for pure joy.
Cultural and Seasonal Notes
Cookie Monster cookies have taken off on social media in the last few years and became the ultimate viral bake. Their blue color is inspired by the classic Sesame Street character and instantly sparks nostalgia and smiles at every party. Around Halloween, try swapping in Halloween Oreo cookies for a spooky twist or use red and green candies for the holidays.
Seasonal Adaptations
Use pastel blue shades for springtime parties Swap in pretzel pieces in summer for extra crunch Top with snowflake sprinkles for a winter theme
Success Stories
Friends and family always light up when these come out of the oven. Once I brought a batch to a school bake sale and every single one sold out before lunch. Even grown up Cookie Monster fans love these for themed parties or movie nights.
Freezer Meal Conversion
Simply shape and stuff the cookies as directed then freeze raw dough balls on a tray. Once solid pop into a freezer bag and bake straight from the freezer adding two or three minutes baking time. It is easy to stock up for surprise celebrations.
Cookie Monster cookies are so much fun to make and even more fun to eat. Once you bake a batch your celebrations will never be the same.
Common Recipe Questions
- → How do I achieve the vibrant blue color?
Use blue gel food coloring to create the signature bright hue. Gel types provide richer color without altering the dough's texture.
- → Why is chilling the dough important?
Chilling helps the dough firm up, prevents spreading in the oven, and enhances the flavor for thicker, chewier cookies.
- → Can I use other cookies for stuffing?
Absolutely! Try any stuffed or sandwich cookie you like for different flavor twists inside the blue cookie dough.
- → What's the best way to keep cookies fresh?
Store them in an airtight container at room temperature for up to a week, or freeze for longer freshness.
- → Is it necessary to use both white and dark chocolate chips?
Mixing both types creates texture and visual contrast, but you can use just one sort or swap for your favorite mix-ins.
- → Can I make the dough ahead of time?
Yes, prepare the dough and chill overnight for convenience and even better flavor development.